|
as to the other review. don't rate low just for the box.even if you do pay a bit extra to have it, it is totally worth it to have a case for the set in my opinion. come on, a 1. (yes, it is just the one volume in included with the box - the price is an indication of that).i feel that the story was engaging, highly entertaining and sexy. and the art is pretty, clean, and consistently wonderful.my roommate, though this is not one of *her* favorites, still wouldn't rate this any lower than a 3. that's low balling it. there are some truly horrible yaoi manga out there that really earn a one star.
The way it was executed was nonsensical and the art was as poor as all three books put together. I have no idea what people like about this book. Taki woke up one morning and thought `I am decidedly straight'. Unfortunately it comes across like something that was improvised frame by frame. If you haven't read Fake I suggest you purchase that instead of this. The first two books have your generic get backers/ legal drug/ jack of all trades half made up storyline.
It doesn't even hold a candle, let alone a matchstick to Fake. There must be something about seeing Dee and Ryo in bishie form that grabs your interest for the first book but once you look past that and at the actual art you'll notice this book aint all its cracked up to be.Goh is definitely gay - it's in his DNA. It's not hard to compare this series to Sanami Matoh's `Fake' as the endings are almost identical. The third book picks up when they start going into the characters pasts and we get left with that ever so enticing cliff hanger. It makes you believe the finale will be a well thought out and well illustrated book. As usual I was fooled by the pretty cover art and overly embellished DMP synopsis/blurb.
I bought this item before it included a description on the page, assuming that a box set would include more than one book. Incidentally, that cardboard box cost me $5.50. Much to my disappointment, I found that this wasn't the case. I am now the proud owner of volume 4 of Yellow and a cardboard box. I strongly recommend Yellow, but save yourself a bunch of money and buy the regular volumes. (Unless, of course, you really want to spend an extra $5.50 on a bit of cardboard).
I got it because I love this series, and the quality of the cardboard is on level with a good anime DVD artbox. throwing themselves at Taki who unfortunately has to turn them all down now lest Goh start crying, and no less than three steamy Goh/Taki love scenes (one involving previously mentioned bindings, even). It features the cover art from volume one's dust jacket and very conveniently has thumb cutouts in the middle so you can actually pull the volumes out of it. The gist of volume four is difficult to sum up without giving away too much. I'd have to say that volume three had all the emotioal power in the series, though if you've gotten this far in the series, finishing it is obligatory (and very satisfactory). Nothing that happens is particularly surprising. I'm also disappointed that the revelations about why Tsunuga's family was targetted are stated and then dropped at the very end of the book.
All the pieces fall nicely into place to get our boys back together and safe from danger, though I have to say Goh's daring seduction of Taki as he was imprisioned at the mercy of his captors was very refreshingly like him. Goh, of course works tirelessly to get him back. "If you're going down, so am I," seemed to be the mantra of our darker haired hero, and he pulled it off with typical Goh bravado. I had expected this series to be a lame rip-off of FAKE, which volume one made it seem like with its never resolving barely tension between Taki and Goh, but it came together beautifully and in some ways exceeded the series that it has come to be compared to the most.
We were left hanging at the end of volume three, but Yellow is back in business in its fourth and final volume.Volume four boasts all of the standard Yellow fare: The obligatory Taki shirt ripping scene (courtesy of Mizuki and a rifle), the obligatory Taki getting the snot beat out of him and then bound scene (courtesy of Katsuro and Mizuki), Goh molesting Taki in public numerous times and getting punched for his efforts, women (and now a few men). We get to go off and witness Taki and Goh's honeymoon together, which is nice and all (very nice, in fact), but there were some loose ends that Tateno-sama failed to tie up for us. Also, we almost got away without having to read through the sort of lame green/red/yellow warning lights explanation, but there it was at the end; sorry folks. You don't however need to pay the extra $4-7 for the artbox release of volume four, which this item is (the standard release is a separate Amazon item, go find it). I'm a little diappointed that Taki's "dark secret" for which he has felt insurmountable regret over for the past six years is neatly taken away so he can live his guilt-free life with Goh happily ever after at the end. and it wrapped most things up very neatly (Unlike you, Finder Series). Basically, Taki has gone off with Katsuro and Mizuki to protect Goh from them. In all, volume four of Yellow puts a very nice end to a surprisingly good Yaoi series.
My complaints with volume four are few. I think this aspect of his past was something that gave his generally chilly emotional state some depth. It didn't run on too long (I'm looking at you, Level C)., it didn't take forever to get released (I'm looking at you, Kizuna). I look forward to future releases from Makoto Tateno, and pray for a day when a Yellow anime is made and brought to our shores.
|
